Automotive glass is cleaned after it comes off the assembly line at Fuyao Glass America’s Moraine, Ohio, plant, in Aug. 2016. Photo credit: BLOOMBERG
Workers at a Chinese-owned auto glass plant in southwestern Ohio voted heavily against union representation, the UAW said late Thursday, in a major blow for the union’s strategy for organizing foreign-owned auto factories.
The union’s defeat comes after a stinging loss it suffered in the U.S. South in August.
The vote, which began on Wednesday, covered roughly 1,500 workers at the Fuyao Glass Industry Group plant in Moraine, a Dayton suburb that was once home to a large, unionized General Motors assembly plant.
The union lost by a nearly two-to-one margin, with 868 votes against union representation and 444 votes for.
“Fuyao workers fighting for a voice in their workplace were unable to win against a barrage of anti-labor tactics and intimidation by management at the Ohio glass plant,” the UAW said in a statement.
Labor experts said the closely watched vote is also an important early sign of the way Chinese investors and companies will manage employee relations as they increase industrial and other operations in the United States.
“We are pleased that FGA associates chose to maintain a direct relationship with our company,” Jeff Daochuan Liu, president of Fuyao Glass America, said in a statement. “While we respect our employees’ right to support or reject a union, we also admire their courage to reject this union’s desperate attempt to prop up its revenue.”
The UAW needed a win after losing a bitterly contested vote at a Nissan Motor Co. plant in Mississippi in August, which extended a decades-long record of failure to organize a major automaker’s plant in the South.
The vote also came amid an expanding U.S. Justice Department probe into alleged misuse of funds at UAW training centers funded by the Detroit automakers.
Fuyao, a Chinese automotive glass supplier whose global customers include General Motors, Ford Motor Co., Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, Daimler AG and Toyota Motor Corp., opened the plant in Moraine in 2016 as part of a broader $ 1 billion expansion in the United States.
Though UAW membership has crept up since the end of the Great Recession, it is around half of what it was in 1998 and well below a peak of 1.5 million members in 1979. Detroit automakers and auto suppliers have slashed workforces at UAW-represented factories over the past 30 years as they have automated and lost sales to European and Asian rivals.
This year could be the first in which North American vehicle production by the unionized Detroit 3 automakers falls to less than half of total vehicle output in the region, according to IHS Markit.
At Fuyao’s Ohio factory, the UAW told workers it could help secure better safety and higher pay.
Rich Rankin, head of the UAW region covering Ohio and Indiana, said workers at the Fuyao plant start at $ 10 an hour, much less than the $ 22 an hour they can make at two other unionized automotive glass plants in his region.
He said he grew up hearing about U.S. companies that would go abroad and pay workers low wages in poor conditions.
“It’s amazing to me that this is now happening to U.S. workers in America’s manufacturing heartland,” he said on Tuesday.
The battle over unionizing at what was once a union-represented GM plant in a state with nearly 50,000 active UAW members drew politicians on both sides.
Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, wrote to Fuyao in October saying its success is “contingent on creating a safe and supportive working environment.”
Meanwhile, 15 Ohio Republican state representatives wrote an open letter urging employees to reject “outside forces” trying to come into the Chinese supplier’s Ohio factory.
Harley Shaiken, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, specializing in labor and the global economy, said while workers had real grievances at the plant, rules preventing unions from talking to workers inside factories played in Fuyao’s favor.
“The employer in this case moved aggressively against the unionizing driver,” he said. “In the current climate of fear among U.S. workers of job losses or plants moving elsewhere, that carried the day.”